Read the epilogue after reading Q, and before the rest of the book. It might make it easier to follow some of the arguments. I think the book would have benefited from a glossary of terms as used the dictionary meanings didn't seem to fully capture the context May 09, Arturo rated it it was amazing. This book will make you think!
This source is supposed to have had quotations from Jesus Christ. Sounds crazy uh? Well the more you read it, the more you will see that it might be possible.
The fact that this is suggested by scholars and not conspiracy nuts is what makes i WOW! The fact that this is suggested by scholars and not conspiracy nuts is what makes it a fantastic reading!
- THE LOST GOSPEL The Book of Q and Christian Origins.
- Perfect, amicable, and sociable numbers : a computational approach.
- Shop by category.
- Like A Wisp of Steam: Steampunk Erotica (The Erotic Steampunk Library Book 1)?
View 1 comment. Shelves: religion. The first assignment in Walter Wink's course on the Christian Scriptures at Union Theological Seminary was to go through the synoptic gospels with magic markers, showing the correspondences of passages between two or more of them. As a consequence of this exercise I developed a firm conviction in the essential accuracy of the Q hypothesis from the German Quelle or "source". The many passages of sayings attributed to Jesus shared by Luke and Matthew indicate a common source not employed by Mark The first assignment in Walter Wink's course on the Christian Scriptures at Union Theological Seminary was to go through the synoptic gospels with magic markers, showing the correspondences of passages between two or more of them.
The many passages of sayings attributed to Jesus shared by Luke and Matthew indicate a common source not employed by Mark. It is one thing to accept the hypothesis of a Sayings Document, another to reconstruct it. This is what Mack attempts to do in The Lost Gospel.
The Lost Gospel: The Book of Q and Christian Origins
The Gospel of Thomas found in Egypt in the forties suggests what a sayings document might have looked like. Mack suggests a more complex model whereby such texts went through stages of development reflecting changing social conditions. This is roughly compatible with Mack's claim that the third and latest stratum, the one following the Roman War, is also the one least represented in the two gospels. However, many scenarios of transmission are imaginable, even those which conceive of scribes reconciling their texts, one to another.
Written for ordinary persons familiar with the bible, Mack's argument is dangerous in that it projects a confidence unwarranted by the evidence. While the probable existence of Sayings Documents is virtually uncontestable, any attempt to reconstruct exemplars beyond the aforementioned Thomas will be debatable until and unless more evidence is obtained. Feb 16, Michael rated it really liked it Shelves: history , religion. An examination of the proposed sayings Gospel known to scholars simply as "Q". The gospel of Q was compiled from content contained within the synoptic gospels of Mark, Matthew, and Luke.
The author argues that this lost gospel was used first by Mark in composing his Gospel, and then later by Matthew and Luke who combined it with Mar's Gospel to create their own accounts. The author goes own to argue that the earliest form of Q highlights Jesus of Nazareth not as a Jewish religious or political r An examination of the proposed sayings Gospel known to scholars simply as "Q".
The author goes own to argue that the earliest form of Q highlights Jesus of Nazareth not as a Jewish religious or political reformer, as the founder of a new religion, or as the promised messiah; rather, Jesus is argued as having been a Stoic sages such as Zeno or Seneca. The Jewish and Christ aspects were tacked on later as the movement grew and faced difficulty following the aftermath of the Jewish revolt.
- Cliffords First Halloween.
- Urdu: An Essential Grammar (Essential Grammars)!
- More items related to this product.
- The Lost Gospel:The Book of Q and Christian Origins | Seminary Co-op Bookstores;
- Your Shopping Cart.
- Subscribe To?
Interesting ideas on Christian origin and worth consideration. Of course, the antiquity and limited historical information on Jesus of Nazareth makes it hard to authenticate any claims on what about him was true. May 22, Sergio E rated it did not like it.
There just isn't enough evidence to convince me that the document hypothesized by the Q hypothesis is anything other than a hypothesis. Because of this, attempt to recreate the contents of this document, and the community that supposedly created it it, are misguided at best. Equally misguided is the idea that such a document, which has absolutely no physical evidence to support its existence, can unlock the mysteries of the "real" Jesus ans "real" Christianity.
Nov 15, Joseph Schrock rated it really liked it. I was inclined to suspect that the author is an atheist or agnostic, given the fact that he seemed extremely cynical about the possibility that the Divine could shine through the lives and teachings of some human beings. It appears that Dr. Mack argues that a mythology was created around the life, death, and supposed resurrection of Jesus.
In conclusion, I will simply say that the book under review here is food for serious thought, reflection, and consideration. It could be a sobering experience and even a wake-up call. Feb 28, Marilyn Fontane rated it it was ok Shelves: history , religion. Mack hypothesizes a new gospel, Q from Quelle, French for source , which he puts together by going backwards from the four or five if you include Thomas narrative gospels and comparing the materials that are identical enough that most scholars on all sides of the question claim Matthew, Mark, Luke, Thomas and John took from a contemporary source of Jesus's sayings.
After abstracting Q from them, he then goes on to interpret why the five have other materials which are different from not only this source, but from one another.
The Lost Gospel: The Book of Q and Christian Origins
Obviously one of the reasons is that the four narrative gospels were written long after Jesus, or his contemporaries, were around to correct them, and many stories and rumors and speculation was available to choose material from. Q, on the other hand, consists of material from no later than the first 40 years of the various Jesus movements. There were many Jesus groups of which Q was only one. Each emphasized ideas important to themselves.
The Jesus of Q is not a political or religious reformer, but similar to a cynic philosopher and teacher. He does not claim to be God or the King of the Jews. He proposes a set of rules for a moral life. His followers are Jesus people, not Christ people Christians. Q is a book of his sayings, his teachings, and there is no reason to study his biography; he is a man, a teacher; his words are what is important. However, years later when each of the authors of the narrative gospels was putting together his material, each had various, and different, agenda in addition to merely writing down a few sayings; the reasons were more nuanced and complex.
Burton L. Mack does not claim that any of them deliberately tried to change Jesus into something he was not, but that time and attitude had changed portions of the population's interpretations as to the significance of Jesus's message. Different groups emphasized different things.
Adding to this are Paul's views who emphasized Jesus's death and mostly ignored his role as a teacher , many bishops' views, etc. Mack covers these differences in detail. He ends up claiming that a cynic teacher with no pretentions to universal greatness based on the gospel of Q which was written during and very shortly after Jesus's lifetime , became bit by bit identified as the Messiah, the anointed or Christ, prophesied in the Jewish literature.
Q shows the original; our own convoluted interpretation of a unity between Matthew, Mark, Luke, John, Thomas, and Paul who do not interpret the same figure at all shows our current Christian view. It then gives the complete text of the gospel and divides it into three parts, depending on when Mack believes it was written. Mack, a professor of New Testament at the School of Theology at Claremont, then provides a background explaining the social and cultural situation of the time and how it influenced the Q people.
After that he shows how the Q material was passed down to, and incorporated by, Thomas, Matthew, and Mark and from Mark to John and Luke. From there he gives details on how Paul and others created our Christian myth. Finally he explains how he feels this knowledge will effect our future beliefs.
The Lost Gospel: The Book of Q and Christian Origins | eBay
Mack thinks his hypothesis will change the church. However it is also possible, and even likely, the church will simply ignore it. Conceptually the book is interesting; it does bog down in the many, many details, however. Anyone interested in the "real" Jesus could profit from reading this work, whatever his orientation to the situation is. Mack presents a human Jesus untouched by divinity; but the scholarly background he uses to present his view should be as useful to anyone who fully believes in the divinity of Jesus as to those who share Mack's own interpretation.
This item will be shipped through the Global Shipping Program and includes international tracking. Learn more - opens in a new window or tab. There are 1 items available. Please enter a number less than or equal to 1. Select a valid country. Please enter 5 or 9 numbers for the ZIP Code. Handling time. Will usually ship within 2 business days of receiving cleared payment - opens in a new window or tab. Taxes may be applicable at checkout. Learn more. Return policy.
Refer to eBay Return policy for more details. You are covered by the eBay Money Back Guarantee if you receive an item that is not as described in the listing. Payment details. Payment methods. Other offers may also be available. Interest will be charged to your account from the purchase date if the balance is not paid in full within 6 months. Minimum monthly payments are required. Subject to credit approval.
Related The Lost Gospel: The Book of Q & Christian Origins
Copyright 2019 - All Right Reserved